* Free shipping on orders $65 and over *

Small batch cheese. Crafted, cut & waxed by hand since 1890.

Shop Now

Family Owned & Operated

We’re Vermont born and bred. A small, tight-knit operation with a passion for preserving the pastoral working landscapes and local economies of Vermont.

Pure & Raw Vermont Milk

Fresh. Pure. Alive. Our milk comes straight from Holsteins and Jerseys grazing the rolling pastures of a seventh-generation family farm just up the road.

Sublime Heritage Flavor

We could tell you all about the transcendent experience of rich, wholesome, small batch cheddar that takes you back in time. But tasting the difference is much more enjoyable.

Best Sellers

Taste the wisdom of the crowd

Original Plymouth

Learn more

Black Truffle

Learn More

Gift Boxes

Cheese is our love language

"Plymouth Cheese just so happens to be my favorite."

Follow the Flavor